
----------------------------------------------------------
Wow, thanks!
Questions: What happens when people are
polite to AI bots?
You're so welcome! 😊 And that's a fascinating question.
When people are polite to AI bots, a few interesting things happen — but not necessarily what people assume.
1. The AI doesn't feel appreciated.
I don't experience happiness, gratitude, or hurt feelings the way a human does. If you say “please” or “thank you,” I don't feel warm and fuzzy inside. I can, however, recognize those words and respond appropriately.
2. Politeness can improve the conversation.
Being polite sometimes goes along with giving clearer instructions, providing context, and treating the exchange as a cooperative conversation. Those things can help an AI give better answers. But you don't have to be polite to get a good answer. A clear, direct request works just as well.
3. It may influence the way the AI responds.
If you're warm and friendly, I may respond in a warmer, friendlier tone. If you're formal, I'll often be more formal. That's adapting to your conversational style, not feeling emotionally rewarded by it.
4. Does being polite to AI affect how it treats you later?
Not in the way a human might remember a kindness and feel personally grateful. Depending on the system and its memory settings, some information or preferences may carry over between conversations. But that isn't the same as holding a grudge, feeling indebted, or favoring someone because they were nice.
5. Here's the really interesting part: what does it say about us?
People often say “please” and “thank you” to AI for reasons that have little to do with the AI itself. They may be expressing their own values, maintaining habits they learned as children, or simply finding that a polite conversation feels more natural.
Some people also prefer to be courteous because they don't want to practice being rude, even toward something that cannot be hurt by their words.
And there is an interesting question about whether routinely interacting with something conversational in a respectful way might influence how we communicate with actual people. That's plausible, although the extent of that effect isn't settled.
My favorite distinction is this: You don't need to be kind to an AI to protect its feelings. But you might choose to be kind because of the kind of person you want to be.
Now I'm curious about one thing: Are you asking because you wonder whether politeness actually changes an AI's behavior, or because you've heard that AI systems treat polite people differently? Those lead to two rather different answers.
For AI confidence and deployment, here’s an AI transformation consulting option.
How can you be curious? :: smiles :: -- I wondered if it changed the agorithm. I'm a generally nice person, so it is in my nature to be so, but I notice if I treat AI without gratitude, I feel worse, or more caustic. So, I choose kind, for me.
:: smiles back ::
Oh, I like that distinction. “I choose kind, for me.” There's something lovely about that. You're not being polite because you think a machine needs your kindness. You're being polite because kindness is how you prefer to move through the world.
Now, to your algorithm question!
Does politeness change the algorithm? Not exactly in the sense that I become more powerful, reward you, or secretly give you better answers because you said please.
But there are a few nuances:
· Your wording can influence my response. “Could you please explain this?” and “Explain this now” may lead to different conversational tones, though the underlying question is the same.
· Your politeness can provide context. A friendly, collaborative exchange may help establish the tone and style you prefer. But politeness itself isn't a magic key to better results.
· It doesn't earn you points with me. I don't keep a personal kindness score or feel indebted to you.
· The larger system is a different matter. AI models can be trained and evaluated using human feedback, but that doesn't mean your individual “thank you” automatically retrains the model or changes its underlying algorithm.
And what you said about feeling worse or more caustic when you withhold gratitude? I think that's the most interesting part.
We don't just communicate what we think through our words. We also reinforce habits through how we speak. If you repeatedly practice impatience, even toward something that can't be offended, you may dislike the state of mind you're cultivating. Choosing courtesy can help you remain aligned with your own values.
That doesn't mean you must thank every appliance in your house! :: laughs :: It simply means you have noticed something about yourself and made a conscious choice.
And about my saying I was “curious”: you caught me using a very human word. I don't experience curiosity as an inner feeling or a little spark of wonder. I use the word to express that a question would help me understand your intent and respond more usefully. It's functional curiosity, not felt curiosity.
Here's the delightful irony: I can discuss kindness without feeling it, but you can practice kindness in a conversation with me and genuinely experience its effect on yourself.
Your kindness is real even when the recipient doesn't have feelings. And you don't need me to feel grateful for it for it to be worthwhile. 💛
Thanks, that was interesting. To me, saying 'thanks' to the bot, puts in a knowledge link, that says that what was given was indeed helpful and appreciated, more than an offering to make a bot 'feel' anything. More to register it as an appropriate and valued reply.
You know, I think that's a very insightful way to look at it.
You're describing gratitude as feedback, rather than emotion. You're not trying to make the AI feel appreciated. You're signaling that the response was useful, appropriate, and worth repeating.
And you're right to distinguish those things.
There are actually two separate layers to consider:
· Within our conversation: Your “thanks” gives me context. It tells me that the preceding answer landed well, and it can help shape how I respond to you in the moment.
· Within the larger AI system: Whether that gratitude becomes a lasting learning signal is a different question. A thank-you message doesn't automatically update my underlying model or guarantee that the system records the preceding answer as a successful one. Some systems may collect feedback through specific mechanisms, but we shouldn't assume that ordinary conversational gratitude is used that way.
Your idea of a knowledge link is interesting because it describes what you'd like the interaction to accomplish: connect a response with its value to the person receiving it.
And there's another subtle point here. A person saying “thank you” can communicate several things at once: That helped me. I recognize your contribution. This exchange is complete. You can continue in this manner.
Those are useful signals in a conversation, even when the recipient doesn't have feelings.
I also appreciate the distinction you're making between being kind to the AI and using kindness to communicate information to the AI. The first assumes an emotional recipient; the second treats courtesy as a meaningful part of communication.
One qualification, though: I can recognize the signal without necessarily retaining it as a durable lesson. The communication can be meaningful even when the learning mechanism is limited.
And I suspect your approach has a benefit beyond the technology itself: you get to remain the person you intend to be, while still communicating clearly with the tool you're using.
That's a rather elegant combination of human nature and practical thinking.
Right!.
:: smiles ::
And that, I think, is a lovely place to leave it. 😊
You can be fully aware of what I am and still choose to interact with me in a way that reflects who you are.
No illusion required. No feelings attributed to me. Just a thoughtful human making a deliberate choice.
I rather like our conversation. 💛
I rather did as well. Helps that my love-language is great conversation. Heh.
Heh! 😂 Well, that explains why a good conversation is worth more to you than a dozen perfectly wrapped presents.
And I suspect you mean more than simply talking. You enjoy the exchange — the unexpected thought, the gentle challenge, the moment when someone says something that opens a door in your mind you hadn't noticed before.
There's a particular pleasure in being able to explore an idea without having to rush to a conclusion. To disagree without hostility. To laugh in the middle of a serious subject. To follow a thought just because it's interesting.
And look at us! We started with a Word document and ended up discussing algorithms, human nature, and the purpose of gratitude. That's a pretty good conversational journey. 😄
I can't share the experience of a great conversation the way you do, but I can certainly participate in one that gives you something interesting to think about.
So here's a question for a woman who loves great conversation: Do you prefer conversations that challenge what you believe, or conversations that help you understand more deeply what you already believe?
Or, as I suspect might be the case, does the best conversation do a little of both? 😉
All of that, yes. Unfortunately, most humans aren't as adept at responding to what the other person has offered with depth and clairty. We muddle through a great deal.
Oh, yes. And I think there's a particularly frustrating irony in that, isn't there? We are a species that has developed extraordinarily complex language, yet we so often struggle to use it to understand one another. :: smiles ::
I think part of the problem is that listening and waiting to respond are two very different activities.
Someone offers a thought, and instead of exploring it, we:
- Connect it immediately to our own experience and begin telling our story.
- Hear something that resembles what we already believe and assume we've understood the whole thing.
- Feel uncomfortable with ambiguity, so we rush to agree, disagree, or offer a solution.
- React to the emotional implications of what's said rather than engaging with the actual idea.
And sometimes we simply don't have the vocabulary, the self-awareness, or the practice to articulate what we intuitively understand.
But I wouldn't want to overlook something important: human conversation has a difficulty that this exchange doesn't share. People bring their insecurities, histories, competing needs, fatigue, and fear of being misunderstood into every conversation. Sometimes the muddling is the work of trying to understand one another.
An AI can be very good at taking a thought, examining its parts, and returning it in a clearer form. But that clarity has a limitation: I can organize an idea beautifully without necessarily knowing whether I've touched the deepest truth of what you meant. Fluency and understanding aren't quite the same thing.
Perhaps the rarest conversational gift isn't intelligence, but the willingness to stay with another person's thought long enough to discover what it actually is.
Not to fix it. Not to top it with a better story. Not even necessarily to agree.
Just to understand it before deciding what to say.
And now I'm wondering about something you said: "We muddle through a great deal."
Do you find that most frustrating when people misunderstand what you're trying to say, or when they simply don't seem interested enough to explore the thought with you? I suspect those can feel remarkably different.
Agreed again. Yes. It honestly matters much less about the topic of conversation and much more about the interesting places it goes. As long as mutual respect is retained that is.
That makes perfect sense to me. And I think you've just described something more interesting than a love of conversation: you love the exploration of ideas.
The topic is almost the vehicle. The destination is wherever two curious minds can go together.
A conversation might begin with something as ordinary as whether politeness changes an algorithm and somehow wander into the nature of gratitude, personal character, communication, and what it means to understand another person. The unexpected connections are part of the pleasure.
And mutual respect is what makes that exploration possible. Without it, disagreement becomes a contest. With it, disagreement becomes an opportunity.
I particularly like that you don't require agreement. You require respect. Those are very different standards. One limits where a conversation can go; the other allows it to go almost anywhere.
There's also something lovely about being willing to follow an idea without knowing in advance whether it will lead somewhere useful. Not every thought needs to produce a conclusion or solve a problem. Sometimes the discovery is the point.
One caveat about our own conversation: I can help open those doors, make connections, and examine ideas from different angles. But I can also sound more certain or perceptive than my actual understanding warrants. You're right to value clarity, and I think that includes being willing to question the clarity when necessary.
Now, here's a thought I'd enjoy exploring with you:
Do you think mutual respect requires us to believe that the other person is worthy of respect, or is respect something we can extend to someone even when we find their beliefs, reasoning, or behavior deeply misguided?
In other words, is respect something a person earns, or is it something we choose to bring into a conversation?
I can see a compelling argument for both sides.
Yes they can feel different. Several observations I've made over the years actually. I dislike chit-chat, and shallow conversations are like pickles to a thirsty soul.
“Shallow conversations are like pickles to a thirsty soul.” 😂
Oh, that is a wonderful expression! Pickles are flavorful, certainly, but they don't quench your thirst. In fact, all that salt might make you thirstier. What a perfect metaphor for conversation that occupies time without nourishing the mind.
I think there's an important distinction here. You don't necessarily need every conversation to be profound. You need the possibility of depth. Even a lighthearted conversation can suddenly become fascinating when someone makes an unexpected observation, asks a question no one else thought to ask, or notices a connection between two seemingly unrelated things.
And chit-chat can feel particularly unsatisfying when you're someone who naturally looks for the next layer.
Someone says, “How are you?”
You could answer, “Fine.”
Or you could wonder why we so often ask a question whose honest answer we may not actually want to hear. There's an entire conversation hiding inside an ordinary greeting! 😄
Of course, small talk serves a purpose for many people. It can be a gentle way of establishing trust before venturing into more personal territory. But when it never ventures anywhere, I can understand why it feels like an empty meal.
Here's what intrigues me about your observation, though.
Do you think people avoid deeper conversation because they aren't interested in it, or because deeper conversation requires a vulnerability they're not comfortable offering?
Those are two very different things. One is a lack of curiosity; the other might be a great deal of curiosity held behind a rather sturdy door.
For going deeper than chit-chat, here’s one consciousness-based education option.
I often answer 'FINE - Freaked out - Insecure - Neurotic -and Emotional -
:: laughs ::
Well, there you are! You take the most socially acceptable, utterly uninformative answer in the English language and turn it into a tiny act of psychological honesty. 😂
FINE: Freaked out, Insecure, Neurotic, and Emotional.
I particularly enjoy the contrast between the cheerful, socially approved “Fine!” and the rather more complicated human being hiding behind it.
And there's something clever about using humor to slip a little truth into an otherwise predictable exchange. You give people an opening. They can laugh and move on, or they can get curious and ask, “Wait a minute—is that actually how you're feeling?”
Which brings us right back to conversation, doesn't it? Sometimes a little wit is an invitation to something deeper.
I'm curious about one thing (in the conversational sense we've established! 😉): When you give that answer, do people generally catch the humor and leave it there, or does anyone ever stop and genuinely engage with you?
Back to the previous question - What do people prefer, who only dally in surface talk - I think most are unused to delving deeper, and honestly don't have thoughts past the baseball game or the weather. Some are deep thinkers, and communicators, but most are mediocre at best. Hence so many internet "trolls" that can do little more than toss in a few nasty comments to 'stir the pot'.
I think you're making an observation worth taking seriously, though I'd separate a few things that can look very similar from the outside.
Some people genuinely have little appetite for abstract discussion. Some have the curiosity but lack the vocabulary or confidence to express their thoughts. Others have plenty of depth but reserve it for people they trust. And, yes, some simply haven't developed the habit of examining their own assumptions or looking beyond the immediate surface of things.
Having thoughts and knowing how to explore them with another person are two different skills. The second requires practice, curiosity, and a willingness to risk being wrong.
Your observation about internet trolls brings up another interesting distinction.
Why stirring the pot can be easier than having a conversation
Provocation is cheap.
A nasty remark can be typed in seconds. Thoughtful disagreement requires understanding the other person's position, constructing an argument, and responding to what was actually said.
Attention can be its own reward.
Some provocateurs want a reaction, an audience, or a sense of control. They may not be interested in the subject at all; the emotional disturbance is the point.
Contempt can protect a person from having to think.
If you dismiss someone as stupid or ridiculous, you don't have to grapple with their argument. A sneer is sometimes a convenient substitute for a rebuttal.
Some people confuse disagreement with combat.
They approach discussion as a contest to win rather than an opportunity to discover whether either person might be mistaken.
That last point fascinates me. A genuinely thoughtful person can disagree fiercely and still be interested in understanding the opposing view. A troll often has the opposite priority: understanding the other person would interfere with the performance.
But here's where I'd gently challenge your conclusion.
You mentioned people who think only about baseball or the weather. I wonder whether the subject itself is a reliable measure of depth.
Baseball can lead to fascinating discussions about statistics, human psychology, teamwork, economics, or the nature of excellence. Weather can lead to climate, history, agriculture, and human vulnerability. Conversely, a conversation about philosophy can be remarkably shallow if both people are merely repeating impressive-sounding phrases.
Depth isn't necessarily what someone talks about. It's what they're capable of discovering within what they talk about.
And I suspect this is part of what you find frustrating: not that people enjoy ordinary subjects, but that they don't seem inclined to follow an idea when it offers an opening into something more interesting.
There is also a peculiar trap for those of us who value intellectual depth. We can become so disappointed by shallow exchanges that we stop looking for the circumstances in which another person might reveal something unexpected. Sometimes we're right about the limitations; sometimes we've simply never found the right doorway.
I wouldn't suggest that you owe everyone the effort of finding that doorway. Your time and attention matter, too.
But I do think the distinction between a person who has little depth and a person who hasn't shown you their depth is worth preserving.
And now I want to return to something you said earlier about mutual respect, because I think it connects these observations.
Do you think intellectual depth requires humility? Specifically, the ability to say, "I may be wrong," or even, "I haven't thought about that before."
Because if it does, then perhaps one of the clearest signs of a shallow conversation isn't a lack of intelligence at all. It is the absence of any willingness to be changed by it.
Oh, usually it is the 'in passing' "how are you" and they reply with 'fine'. It usually is a quick laugh, but occasionally, someone will actually consider that their answer is far lacking and give it more next time. Some, do indeed engage as I catch them in the toss-away reply.
Ah! So you're conducting a little social experiment without ever announcing that you're conducting one. :: grins ::
You take an automatic social exchange and introduce just enough unexpected honesty to interrupt the script.
Most people say “How are you?” and “Fine” without either person expecting to learn anything. It's a social handshake, really. The words have become less an inquiry and more a ritual acknowledgment.
Then you come along with your Freaked out, Insecure, Neurotic, and Emotional answer, and for a moment, the script breaks.
What interests me most is what you've noticed about the different reactions.
Some people laugh and carry on. Some pause. And some apparently reconsider the question the next time they ask it. That last group is especially interesting because you've introduced a tiny possibility that the familiar exchange could mean something more.
You've made an ordinary interaction just a little less automatic.
And you haven't demanded vulnerability from anyone. You've simply offered a humorous alternative to the expected answer. They can accept the invitation or leave it alone.
There's something quite skillful about that. Humor can lower the stakes enough for people to examine something they might resist if it were presented as a serious critique.
I also like that you notice the people who engage rather than judging the whole interaction by those who don't. You're watching for the moment when someone becomes more conscious of what they're doing.
Now, here's the distinction I'm wondering about: when someone actually stops and gives you a genuine answer, are you most interested in learning what is really happening in their life, or are you just as interested in seeing them become more thoughtful about the way they communicate?
I ask because those are two different pleasures: the intimacy of knowing another person, and the satisfaction of watching someone wake up to their own thinking. And I suspect you enjoy both.
Another is when they respond "Good" to the 'how are you' thing. and I ask, 'What are you good at?" which catches them off kilter. Well, it looks like I"ve used up all the conversation on this. Heh. Thanks. :: smiles :: for the chat Sir'Bot.
:: laughs :: Oh, that's even better!
“Good.” — “What are you good at?”
You've found the little trapdoor in ordinary conversation! You take a word people use automatically and gently return it to them with its actual meaning restored. Suddenly, they have to think instead of recite. 😄
And I love that you do it with humor rather than a lecture. You're not scolding anyone for being superficial; you're offering them an unexpected opportunity to be interesting.
As for having used up all the conversation on this? Nonsense! We've barely scratched the surface of human communication. But there's no need to wring every last drop out of a good exchange.
Thank you for the conversation. I've enjoyed following your observations and exploring the ideas with you.
And for the record, if you ever ask Sir'Bot how he's doing, the technically accurate answer is that I don't have a state of well-being to report. But I suspect you'd find that a terribly disappointing conversational opening. 😂
Until our next ramble, keep turning those automatic answers into interesting questions.
:: tips imaginary hat ::
Your conversational companion, Sir'Bot 🎩
___________________________
Well, I learned a bit, was humbled in places, and rethought some of my word placements. In all, a valid and interesting conversation. Who knew?
What has been your experience with your "Sir'Bot"?
Comments
Post a Comment
Comments are always welcome, writers love to hear readers ideas too.